Sheriff Court vs Court of Session for Personal Injury Claims Scotland
In Scotland, personal injury claims are raised in either the Sheriff Court or the Court of Session depending on the value and complexity of the claim. The vast majority of PI claims are handled by the Sheriff Court or the All-Scotland Sheriff Personal Injury Court.
Key Points — Quick Summary
- ✓Most personal injury claims in Scotland are raised in the Sheriff Court or the All-Scotland Sheriff Personal Injury Court (ASPIC).
- ✓The Court of Session in Edinburgh handles high-value claims (typically over £100,000) and complex litigation.
- ✓ASPIC was established in 2015 to give Sheriff Court litigants access to specialist personal injury procedure.
- ✓Court of Session actions are more expensive but may recover higher expenses in successful high-value claims.
- ✓Your solicitor will advise which court is most appropriate for your specific claim.
[LAW FIRM NAME] — specialist personal injury and accident claim solicitors in Scotland.
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Always seek independent legal advice before taking any action. Editorial standards →
In Scotland, most personal injury claims are handled by the Sheriff Court or the All-Scotland Sheriff Personal Injury Court. The Court of Session deals with higher-value and more complex claims. Your solicitor will choose the most appropriate court based on the value, complexity and tactical considerations of your specific claim.
The Sheriff Court — Scotland's Main PI Court
The Sheriff Court is Scotland's main civil court and handles the vast majority of personal injury claims. Scotland has 39 sheriff court buildings across the country. Claims can be raised in the sheriff court local to where the accident occurred, where the defender is based, or — for claims above £5,000 — in the All-Scotland Sheriff Personal Injury Court in Edinburgh.
The All-Scotland Sheriff Personal Injury Court (ASPIC)
The ASPIC was established in 2015 specifically to handle personal injury claims with a value above £5,000 raised as Sheriff Court actions. It is based at Sheriff Court House, Edinburgh, and has specialist sheriffs with expertise in personal injury litigation. ASPIC uses its own bespoke procedural rules designed for efficient case management of PI claims and sits at the intersection of Sheriff Court and Court of Session practice.
The Court of Session — High-Value and Complex Claims
The Court of Session is Scotland's supreme civil court, sitting in Parliament House in Edinburgh. It handles higher-value personal injury claims — typically those above £100,000 — and claims involving particularly complex legal issues. Court of Session procedure is more formal and expensive than Sheriff Court procedure, but the scale of recoverable expenses is higher, which can make it advantageous in large, successful claims.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Sheriff Court / ASPIC | Court of Session |
|---|---|---|
| Typical claim value | Under £100,000 (most PI claims) | Over £100,000 or complex claims |
| Location | Local sheriff court (throughout Scotland) | Parliament House, Edinburgh only |
| Specialist PI court | All-Scotland Sheriff PI Court (ASPIC) for claims over £5,000 | Inner House / Outer House |
| Procedure | Ordinary cause / summary cause procedure | Court of Session rules — more complex |
| Court fees | Lower | Higher |
| Recoverable expenses | Party-and-party scale (lower) | Higher scale — better recovery in large claims |
| Appeal route | Sheriff Appeal Court → Court of Session | Inner House → UK Supreme Court |
| Time to resolution | Generally faster | Often longer in complex litigation |
| Case management | Active case management in ASPIC | Active management in commercial/PI rolls |
Which Court Will My Claim Be Raised In?
Your solicitor will advise on the appropriate court based on the estimated value of your claim, its complexity, the likely costs and the tactical advantages of each forum. You do not normally need to make this decision yourself. For most straightforward personal injury claims, the Sheriff Court or ASPIC will be the appropriate forum.
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to Check If You Can Claim?
Speak to a Scottish claims specialist today. Your enquiry is free, confidential and carries no obligation.
No win, no fee available. No obligation. Time limits apply.